Severity 3 — Serious⚖️ rights14 March 2019

Suppression of "We Want to Live" Protests

Gaza residents protesting Hamas's own economic mismanagement, taxation, and the broader blockade's hardships under the "We Want to Live" banner were met with beatings and mass arrests by Hamas internal security forces, who also detained and assaulted journalists covering the demonstrations — a rare instance of Hamas suppressing dissent aimed squarely at its own governance rather than at Israel.

H

Hamas Political Bureau (Gaza only, from 2007) — Hamas

In power 2006–present

What happened

The protests were notable precisely because they broke with the conflict's usual framing: demonstrators, mostly young Gazans facing unemployment estimated at well over 40% at the time, blamed Hamas's own governance — new taxes on basic goods, a bloated and unaccountable public sector, and the group's continued prioritisation of its military wing's spending over civilian welfare — rather than solely blaming Israel's blockade, which Hamas's own officials had long pointed to as the sole cause of Gaza's economic hardship.

Hamas's response was to treat the protests as a security threat rather than a legitimate grievance: HRW documented named individuals being summoned for interrogation, beaten in custody, and in some cases held for weeks, while journalists attempting to film the demonstrations had their equipment confiscated and were themselves assaulted or detained by Hamas's internal security services. The crackdown succeeded in suppressing the movement within weeks, and no comparable protest movement against Hamas's own rule emerged again until pressures generated by the 2023-2025 war and its aftermath. The episode is a useful data point against any account of Gaza politics that treats Hamas purely as a resistance movement responding to external pressure — this was Hamas suppressing its own population's economic grievances using the same security apparatus it has used against political rivals more broadly.

Source

Human Rights Watch — Gaza: Hamas Stifles "We Want to Live" Protests

🌍 See this event in context

This event is one entry in Palestine's accountability record. Open the interactive map to see the full timeline, polling data, and every documented event.

🌍 View on the map